Canisius University Seeks Reopening of Lyons Hall Amidst Legal and Insurance Disputes

By: Delaney Hayden, Asst. News Editor 

Canisius University is working to restore and potentially reopen Lyons Hall, an academic building severely damaged during the winter blizzard that struck Buffalo in late December 2022. This is an ongoing story. 

Initially, the university had declared that they would not return to the building due to its extensive water damage. The recent developments, however, suggest a shift in this assessment as Canisius explores the feasibility of restoring the nearly century-old structure.

Lyons Hall, acquired by Canisius in July 2006 for $1.65 million, served as a great resource for the university. It housed the admissions, alumni engagement, communications and enrollment management offices, as well as the Marie Maday Theatre and several academic departments. The damage assessment revealed that multiple pipes burst on the building’s third floor, causing extensive water damage across all lower levels, including the basement. Substantial repairs are needed, including removing plaster and drywall, replacing equipment, treating mold and reassessing plumbing and heating systems.

The university's ability to move forward with restoration rides on its ongoing legal dispute with its insurance provider, Travelers Insurance. Canisius is challenging Travelers in court over the amount required for the building’s repair. 

According to Katie Anderson of Buffalo Business First, Canisius estimates that restoring Lyons Hall will cost approximately $24.7 million. This estimate covers repairs to the building's electrical, plumbing, HVAC, and fire suppression systems. In contrast, Travelers Insurance has paid out $11.7 million, leaving a $12.3 million shortfall that Canisius claims is necessary to complete the restoration.

As we reported last year, Canisius President Steve Stoute had previously indicated that the building would no longer be used by Canisius. However, the new information now suggests that if Canisius secures a fair settlement with Travelers, the university may be able to restore the building to its former condition.

Restoring Lyons Hall will allow for Canisius University to modernize facilities that enhance the student experience and support the university’s goals. The resolution of the legal and insurance disputes will be pivotal in determining whether Canisius can successfully restore this landmark and continue to utilize its space for learning, education and growth of its students’ minds.